Records versus Opponents (1918/19-2023/24)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Ada

0

1

.000

Akron Ellet

1

2

.333

Akron South

0

1

.000

Alumni

4

6

.400

Ashland

36

72

.333

Athens

1

1

.500

Bath

3

6

.333

Bellevue

1

3

.250

Benjamin Logan

4

0

1.000

Bexley

15

13

.535

Big Walnut

9

7

.562

Bowling Green

5

7

.416

Buckeye Valley

9

10

.473

Bucyrus

41

16

.719

Cambridge

0

2

.000

Canal Winchester

0

1

.000

Canton McKinley

0

1

.000

Cardington-Lincoln

1

1

.500

Celina

0

1

.000

Central Crossing

0

2

.000

Circleville

2

0

1.000

Clear Fork

11

4

.733

Cleveland East

3

1

.750

Cleveland Lutheran East

1

0

1.000

Cleveland West

0

1

.000

Columbus Academy

1

1

.500

Columbus Africentric

1

3

.250

Columbus Aquinas

7

2

.777

Closed - Building purchased by Columbus State in early 60s

Columbus Beechcroft

1

1

.500

Columbus Briggs

8

5

.615

Columbus Brookhaven

2

7

.222

(1963/64-2013/14)

Columbus Centennial

1

0

1.000

Columbus Central

3

12

.200

Named Columbus Commerce early 1900s; Closed after 1980/81 school year; ; Currently COSI

Columbus DeSales

1

1

.500

Columbus East

1

7

.125

Columbus Eastmoor

0

2

.000

Columbus Hartley

1

1

.500

Columbus Linden McKinley

0

1

.000

Columbus Marion-Franklin

3

7

.300

Columbus Mifflin

0

1

.000

Columbus North

10

15

.400

Columbus Northland

3

1

.750

Columbus South

2

8

.200

Columbus Walnut Ridge

0

2

.000

Columbus Watterson

1

5

.166

Columbus West

10

13

.434

Columbus Whetstone

4

1

.800

Coshocton

0

1

.000

Crestline

6

0

1.000

Dayton Belmont

2

0

1.000

Dayton Steele

1

0

1.000

Dayton Stivers

1

1

.500

Defiance

3

3

.500

Delaware Hayes

9

23

.281

Delaware Willis

34

16

1.000

Build new school Delaware Hayes (1962/63); includes all pre-Hayes games

Dublin

1

1

.500

Split into Dublin Coffman and Dublin Scioto

Dublin Coffman

0

1

.000

Dublin Jerome

0

4

.000

Dublin Scioto

0

12

.000

Elida

7

5

.583

Elyria

19

46

.292

Faculty

1

0

1.000

Fairbanks

5

0

1.000

Faith Christian Academy, FL

1

0

1.000

Findlay

29

81

.263

Fostoria

14

10

.583

Franklin Heights

0

3

.000

Fremont Ross

55

45

.550

Gahanna Lincoln

2

5

.285

Galion

81

19

.810

Grandview

5

2

.714

Grove City

1

0

1.000

Groveport-Madison

1

4

.200

Highland

10

1

.909

Hilliard

1

3

.250

Split into Hilliard Davidson (original school) and Hilliard Darby

Hilliard Bradley

0

3

.000

Hilliard Darby

0

1

.000

Hilliard Davidson

1

0

1.000

Huntington, West Virginia

1

0

1.000

Huntsville

1

0

1.000

Huron

1

0

1.000

Indian Valley

1

0

1.000

Jonathan Alder

5

8

.384

Kenton

32

20

.615

Lake Buena Vista, FL

1

0

1.000

Lakewood

1

0

1.000

Lancaster

2

5

.285

Lexington

6

34

.150

Liberty Five

1

0

1.000

Semi-Pro team?

Lima Central

2

2

.500

Consolidated into Lima Senior (1955/56)

Lima Central Catholic

3

1

.750

Lima Senior

11

21

.343

Lima South

4

3

.571

Consolidated into Lima Senior (1955/56)

Lorain

5

9

.357

Split into Lorain Senior and Lorain Admiral King (1961/62)

Lorain Admiral King

12

38

.240

Lorain Senior

25

27

.480

Became Middle School after 1994/95 school year (Old Lorain High School)

Madison

17

30

.361

Mansfield Malabar

2

6

.250

Mansfield Senior

32

88

.266

Includes Mansfield High School

Mansfield St. Peter’s

5

2

.714

Mansfield Temple Christian

2

0

1.000

Marietta

0

1

.000

Marion City Team

1

0

1.000

Industrial, YMCA or Semi-Pro team

Marysville

10

6

.625

Monroe

0

1

.000

Not sure which Monroe they played (Madison [Jonathan Alder] or Pickaway [Westfall])

Monsignor, Farrell, NY

0

1

.000

Montpelier

0

1

.000

Mt. Vernon

17

26

.395

Napoleon

5

12

.294

Newark

10

24

.294

North Lewisburg

1

0

1.000

Consolidated into Triad

North Union

6

3

.666

Northmor

0

1

.000

Norwalk

0

4

.000

Olentangy

2

4

.333

Olentangy Berlin

0

1

.000

Olentangy Liberty

2

2

.500

Olentangy Orange

0

4

.000

Ontario

7

8

.466

Orrville

3

4

.428

Perkins

3

0

1.000

Pickerington

0

1

.000

Pleasant

13

7

.650

Prospect

1

0

1.000

Consolidated into Elgin (1962/63)

Reynoldsburg

0

2

.000

Ridgedale

3

1

.750

River Valley

14

9

.608

Rossford

1

0

1.000

Sandusky

40

48

.454

Shawnee

2

8

.250

Shekinah Christian

1

1

.500

Shelby

42

23

.646

Sheridan

1

1

.500

Shovel-Y Indus

1

1

.500

Industrial League team

Springfield

2

4

.333

Split into Springfield North and Springfield South; Merged into Springfield (2006/07)

St. Marys

1

0

1.000

1919/20 game - not sure if Marion St. Mary, Auglaize County St. Marys or Church team

Teays Valley

0

1

.000

Thomas Worthington

4

4

.500

Tiffin Calvert

1

0

1.000

Tiffin Columbian

15

18

.454

Tiffin Junior Order

2

2

.500

Closed after 1942/43

Toledo Central Catholic

1

0

1.000

Toledo DeVilbiss

2

2

.500

Closed 1991

Toledo Libbey

0

1

.000

Toledo Scott

1

2

.333

Toledo Waite

0

1

.000

Triad

1

0

1.000

Upper Sandusky

18

5

.782

Upper Scioto Valley

0

2

.000

Urbana

1

1

.500

Van Wert

2

0

1.000

Vermilion

8

2

.800

Wapakoneta

5

6

.454

Washington Court House

2

0

1.000

Watkins Memorial

0

1

.000

Westerville

3

0

1.000

Westerville North

3

6

.333

Westland

1

5

.166

Willard

13

3

.812

Willoughby

1

0

1.000

Worthington

3

5

.375

Split into Thomas Worthington and Worthington Kilbourne (1991/92)

Worthington Kilbourne

1

3

.250

Zanesville

1

5

.166

Totals

947

1125

.457

Records versus North Central Ohio League Opponents (1919/20-1944/45)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Ashland

19

22

.463

Bucyrus

25

10

.714

Delaware Willis

7

7

.500

Galion

37

4

.902

Mansfield Senior

8

18

.307

Mt. Vernon

15

5

.750

Shelby

26

9

.742

Totals

137

75

.646

Records versus Buckeye League Opponents (1949/50-1953/54)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Bowling Green

4

5

.444

Findlay

2

5

.142

Fostoria

5

5

.500

Fremont Ross

3

5

.375

Tiffin Columbian

7

3

.700

Totals

21

23

.477

Records versus Buckeye Conference Opponents (1954/55-1986/87)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Elyria

19

45

.296

Findlay

23

42

.353

Fremont Ross

42

23

.646

Lorain

5

8

.466

Split into Lorain Senior and Lorain Admiral King (1961/62)

Lorain Admiral King

12

38

.240

Lorain Senior

25

27

.480

Became Middle School after 1994/95 school year

Mansfield Senior

18

20

.473

Sandusky

32

33

.492

Totals

176

236

.427

Records versus Ohio Heartland Conference Opponents (1987/88-2002/03)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Ashland

8

24

.250

Lexington

3

29

.093

Madison

11

21

.343

Mansfield Malabar

1

3

.250

Mansfield Senior

0

32

.000

Orrville

3

4

.428

Vermilion

8

0

1.000

Totals

34

113

.231

Records versus Greater Buckeye Conference Opponents (2003/04-2010/11)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Findlay

3

13

.187

Fremont Ross

6

10

.375

Lima Senior

4

12

.250

Napoleon

4

12

.250

Sandusky

3

13

.187

Totals

20

60

.250

Records versus Mid-Ohio Athletic Conference Opponents (2014/15-2023/24)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Buckeye Valley

5

5

.500

Clear Fork

10

4

.714

Fairbanks

4

0

1.000

Galion

18

2

.900

Highland

6

0

1.000

Jonathan Alder

3

3

.500

North Union

6

2

.750

Ontario

6

8

.428

Pleasant

13

7

.650

River Valley

13

7

.650

Shelby

3

9

.250

Totals

87

47

.649

Records versus Tournament Opponents (1918/19-2023/24)

Versus

W

L

PCT

NOTES

Akron South

0

1

.000

Ashland

3

4

.428

Bexley

3

1

.750

Bowling Green

1

2

.333

Bucyrus

7

0

1.000

Canal Winchester

0

1

.000

Celina

0

1

.000

Circleville

2

0

1.000

Clear Fork

1

0

1.000

Cleveland West

0

1

.000

Columbus Aquinas

2

1

.666

Columbus Brookhaven

0

3

.000

(1963/64-2013/14)

Columbus Central

3

7

.300

Closed after 1980/81 school year

Columbus East

1

5

.166

Columbus Eastmoor

0

1

.000

Columbus Linden McKinley

0

1

.000

Columbus Marion-Franklin

0

1

.000

Columbus Mifflin

0

1

.000

Columbus North

4

4

.500

Columbus Northland

1

1

.500

Columbus South

1

4

.250

Columbus Walnut Ridge

0

2

.000

Columbus West

4

0

1.000

Crestline

4

0

1.000

Defiance

3

3

.500

Delaware Hayes

1

0

1.000

Delaware Willis

4

1

.800

Dublin

1

1

.500

Split into Dublin Coffman and Dublin Scioto

Dublin Coffman

0

1

.000

Elyria

0

1

.000

Findlay

0

4

.000

Franklin Heights

0

1

.000

Fremont Ross

1

1

.500

Galion

1

1

.500

Grandview

5

2

.625

Grove City

1

0

1.000

Groveport-Madison

0

1

.000

Hilliard

0

1

.000

Becomes Hilliard Davidson High School when Hilliard Darby opens (1996/97)

Hilliard Bradley

0

3

.000

Hilliard Darby

0

1

.000

Huntsville

1

0

1.000

Huron

1

0

1.000

Lakewood

1

0

1.000

Lancaster

1

0

1.000

Lima Central Catholic

0

1

.000

Lima Senior

4

3

.571

Lorain

0

1

.000

Madison

3

1

.750

Mansfield Senior

4

7

.363

Mansfield St. Peter’s

2

0

1.000

Marietta

0

1

.000

Mt. Vernon

1

1

.500

Napoleon

1

0

1.000

Newark

0

8

.000

Norwalk

0

2

.000

Olentangy

1

0

1.000

Olentangy Berlin

0

1

.000

Ontario

1

0

1.000

Perkins

1

0

1.000

Reynoldsburg

0

1

.000

Rossford

1

0

1.000

Sandusky

1

1

.500

Shawnee

1

4

.200

Shelby

5

1

833

Teays Valley

0

1

.000

Thomas Worthington

0

2

.000

Tiffin Calvert

1

0

1.000

Tiffin Columbian

1

1

.500

Toledo Central Catholic

1

0

1.000

Upper Sandusky

3

1

.750

Urbana

1

0

1.000

Wapakoneta

1

2

.333

Washington Court House

1

0

1.000

Westerville

3

0

1.000

Westerville North

0

1

.000

Westland

0

1

.000

Willard

1

0

1.000

Worthington

1

0

1.000

Split into Thomas Worthington and Worthington Kilbourne (1991/92)

Totals

98

108

.475